Why do major labels get the biggest cuts while small artists struggle?

A significant portion of the revenue from platforms like Spotify, Apple Music, and others goes to record labels. This distribution can be quite uneven: ...

major record labels often receive larger shares than independent or smaller artists. To understand this inequality, one must examine the complex economic model of the music industry and its impact on the various players.

---

1. The Basics of Streaming Royalties
2. The Role of Major Labels
3. The Struggle of Indie Artists
4. Factors Influencing Royalty Payments
5. Implications of Uneven Royalties
6. Conclusion

---

1.) The Basics of Streaming Royalties

When a user streams a song on a platform like Spotify, Apple Music, or any other digital streaming service, some portion of that revenue is paid out to the copyright owner (typically the record label). This payment depends largely on agreements between the service and the rights holders, including both major labels and indie artists. These agreements can be either direct deals where the service pays a fixed royalty rate per stream directly to the artist or through an intermediary like a label who negotiates a larger deal with the streaming platform.

---

2.) The Role of Major Labels

Major record companies often have extensive catalogs that include thousands, if not tens of thousands, of songs by various artists. These labels benefit from economies of scale in negotiations with platforms because they can offer access to a vast library of music. As such, major labels negotiate typically larger royalty deals than independent or smaller labels due to their size and market power.

---

3.) The Struggle of Indie Artists

Indie artists, on the other hand, often have fewer resources at their disposal for negotiation. They might have only one or a few songs in the platform's catalog, which limits their negotiating power with streaming services. Moreover, many indie labels don't have the financial muscle to negotiate favorable terms. As a result, they end up receiving smaller royalty payments compared to major labels, despite potentially having equally talented and popular artists.

---

4.) Factors Influencing Royalty Payments

1. Negotiation Power: Major labels with more extensive catalogs generally have greater negotiating power, allowing them to secure better royalty deals than indie artists who are typically solo acts or in very small teams.
2. Contractual Obligations: Independent artists might be under contract with a label that has negotiated terms favorable for the label but less so for the artist. These contracts often include clauses where artists receive minimal payments regardless of streaming volume, which is another factor contributing to their financial struggles.
3. Economies of Scale: Major labels can spread the costs of negotiating deals across multiple titles in their catalog, making each individual track more profitable under their agreements with streaming services. This doesn't directly impact indie artists who have no such economies.
4. Market Power and Distribution Deals: Streaming platforms often strike direct deals with major labels for preferred distribution and exposure, which can lead to larger payouts than what smaller labels or independent artists receive through normal negotiation processes.

---

5.) Implications of Uneven Royalties

1. Financial Burden on Indie Artists: The lower royalty payments mean indie artists face greater financial challenges in sustaining their creative output and maintaining a career in music compared to major label artists who can recoup more from streaming revenue.
2. Diversity of the Music Industry: This imbalance can lead to less diversity in musical styles, as only those with substantial resources (like major labels) have the potential to thrive commercially. Smaller labels and indie artists might struggle to break through due to financial constraints that limit their promotional efforts and creative freedom.
3. Long-term Sustainability: The disparity could potentially affect the long-term sustainability of independent music, leading to fewer new talents entering the industry or a decrease in the diversity of musical content available for consumers.

---

6.) Conclusion

The uneven distribution of streaming royalties between major labels and indie artists is rooted in differences in negotiation power, contractual obligations, economies of scale, and market dynamics. While this model benefits larger entities with more extensive catalogs and resources, it can be detrimental to the financial health and creative freedom of smaller-scale artists. Balancing these imbalances would require a nuanced understanding of each artist's value within their catalog and potentially reevaluating how streaming royalties are calculated and distributed across all parties involved in the music industry ecosystem.

---

The Autor: Web3WTF / Xia 2025-05-20