The ‘E.T. Effect’: Why Some Games Are Hated Until They’re Loved

The gaming world is full of legends, myths, and controversies that shape our perception of certain games over time. One such phenomenon is the "ET ...

Effect," named after the infamous Atari game that was widely reviled upon its release in 1982. This blog post explores why some games are initially hated but eventually achieve cult status and recognition.

---

1. Understanding the 'E.T. Effect'
2. Factors Contributing to the 'E.T. Effect'
3. Examples of Games That Exhibit the 'E.T. Effect'
4. Conclusion: Why Some Games Are Hated Until They’re Loved

---

1.) Understanding the 'E.T. Effect'

The term ‘E.T. Effect’ refers to how video games, particularly those that receive poor reviews or negative press upon release, can experience a turnaround in their reputation over time. This change in perception often leads to increased interest, critical reevaluation, and even renewed appreciation for these once-maligned titles.

The Atari Factor: E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)

E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial is a prime example of a game that suffered from poor marketing, bad timing, and negative press. Released in 1982 around the same time as Steven Spielberg’s movie ET, the game was criticized for its graphics, gameplay mechanics, and storyline-all factors contributing to it being one of the worst video games ever made according to some critics.

The Rise of Hate-to-Love

Over time, gamers and critics began to reassess E.T., discovering that while it wasn’t a masterpiece, there were elements worth appreciating: the story was heartfelt for its era, and gameplay mechanics had some depth if approached in a different way. This reevaluation led to an increase in sales as fans who discovered the game later appreciated its merits.

---

2.) Factors Contributing to the 'E.T. Effect'

1. Time

One of the most significant factors is simply time. As generations come and go, attitudes towards gaming change. What was considered bad or shallow twenty years ago might be seen as a nostalgic relic today by younger gamers who appreciate its historical value or unique qualities.

2. Reevaluation in Perspective

With hindsight, especially when games are compared to modern standards, some older titles may seem primitive but offer gameplay elements that newer games lack due to technological constraints of the time (e.g., limited memory and processing power). This reevaluation allows gamers to appreciate these old games on their own terms rather than through today’s more sophisticated gaming lens.

3. Cult Following

Sometimes, despite initial negative reactions, a small but passionate group of fans may latch onto the game, finding enjoyment or appreciation in ways others don't. This cult following can lead to an underground appreciation society that champions these games against mainstream criticism.

4. Cultural References and Memes

Social media has played a significant role in how we perceive and discuss video games. Negative opinions about certain titles can become meme-ified or referenced widely enough for people to feel like they must engage with the game if they want to be part of the conversation. This social pressure contributes to increased visibility and interest.

---

3.) Examples of Games That Exhibit the 'E.T. Effect'

1. Duke Nukem Forever (2011)

Released after a long development hell, Duke Nukem Forever was met with widespread derision upon its release in 2011 mainly due to its dated gameplay mechanics and humor style compared to modern standards. However, the game saw a resurgence of interest when fans started making memes about it online, leading to increased sales and reevaluations by critics and players alike.

2. Myst (1993)

Myst was initially met with mixed reviews for its complex puzzles and slow pace compared to other games of the time. Over the years, however, it has been recognized for its innovative use of graphics and storytelling that set a new standard for adventure games. The game now regularly appears in top lists of greatest video games due to this reevaluation over time.

---

4.) Conclusion: Why Some Games Are Hated Until They’re Loved

The 'E.T. Effect' highlights how perceptions can change dramatically with the passage of time and cultural shifts. What starts as a universally despised game often gains appreciation when seen through fresh eyes, potentially because newer generations appreciate games on different criteria than their predecessors. The rise in popularity of retro gaming culture also plays a significant role in this phenomenon.

Understanding why certain games exhibit the 'E.T. Effect' helps us recognize that there’s more to video game criticism than just technical specs and sales figures, and it invites players and critics alike to reconsider old favorites or lesser-known gems based on their merits rather than initial impressions.

---

The Autor: GANja / Kenji 2025-06-28