How to Accidentally Make DLC That Feels Mandatory

We often find ourselves in a phase of excitement when our game's initial release is met with positive feedback. However, this phase can quickly turn into ...

frustration when players express dissatisfaction with various aspects of the game—particularly DLC (downloadable content). This blog post explores how you can accidentally create DLC that feels mandatory and how to navigate these situations to ensure a healthy relationship between your game and its player base.

---

1. Understanding Player Expectations
2. Avoiding Frustration Triggers
3. Overcoming Game Failures with DLC

---

1.) Understanding Player Expectations

First and foremost, it's crucial to understand why players might feel compelled to purchase DLC. Often, this stems from the perceived value proposition-players may feel that certain content was either promised or implied but not delivered in the original release. To avoid making your DLC feel mandatory, consider these tips:

1. Transparent Communication

Ensure clear and consistent communication about what will be included in future updates or DLCs. This includes transparency regarding new features, improvements, and any post-release content plans. Players appreciate knowing what to expect and are less likely to feel pressured into buying additional content if they understand its purpose and value.

2. Quality Over Quantity

Focus on creating high-quality content that enhances the core gameplay experience rather than flooding the game with unnecessary DLCs just for the sake of revenue. Players can sense when a game is trying too hard to sell them something, which can lead to frustration and disengagement.

---

2.) Avoiding Frustration Triggers

Developers often make mistakes that inadvertently push players towards feeling obligated to buy DLCs. Here are some common pitfalls to avoid:

1. Sudden Price Increases

While it's natural for prices to increase over time due to inflation or increased production costs, making significant price hikes without clear justification can be frustrating. Players may feel that they are being forced into a purchase because of financial pressure rather than the perceived value of the content itself.

2. Exclusive Content Trap

Offering exclusive content (e.g., items, characters) that only DLC provides might seem like a good way to boost sales but can backfire if players perceive this as forcing them to spend money or feel left out. Consider how important it is for these features to be tied to the DLC and whether they could have been included in a free update.

---

3.) Overcoming Game Failures with DLC

Even with the best intentions, sometimes games might fail commercially. Here's how you can use DLC as a strategic response:

1. Post-Launch Support

If your game underperforms initially, consider it an opportunity to learn and adapt rather than a failure. Use DLC as a platform to listen to player feedback and implement changes based on real-world performance data. This could include fixing bugs, improving mechanics, or adding new content that resonates with the community.

2. Strategic Content Rollouts

Instead of rushing multiple large DLCs at once, consider releasing smaller, focused updates first. These can serve as test markets to see what players like and dislike before committing to more extensive expansions. This approach allows you to refine your strategy based on player engagement and feedback.

In conclusion, creating DLC that feels mandatory is a delicate balance between providing valuable content and respecting the consumer's wallet. By focusing on clear communication, quality over quantity, avoiding frustrating practices such as sudden price hikes and exclusive content traps, and using DLC strategically during times of game failure or initial underperformance, you can build a more sustainable and player-friendly approach to post-launch support.

---

The Autor: Doomscroll / Jamal 2025-05-25